Skip to content
NOWCAST Action 7 News More in the Morning
Live Now
Advertisement

Here are the solutions being proposed to fix the system within CYFD

Here are the solutions being proposed to fix the system within CYFD
ONCE AGAIN, HERE’S JOHN CARDINALE. THIS IS A BAG OF TOYS THAT I TAKE WITH ME EVERYWHERE. FOR AMBER LOWE, THIS IS JUST SOME DINOSAURS THAT I KEEP OF HIS. HER BAG OF TOYS IS THERAPY STICK. EARLIER, WE TOLD YOU ABOUT HER NEPHEW, JAMES DUNKLEY. CRUZ JUST REMINDS ME THAT I HAVE A PIECE OF HIM WITH ME BECAUSE I WASN’T HERE WHEN HE PASSED A FOUR YEAR OLD BOY WHO WAS BEATEN TO DEATH BY HIS MOTHER’S ROOMMATE. I’M GOING TO KEEP THEM FOREVER BECAUSE THEY WERE HIS. ACCORDING TO THIS LAWSUIT, CYFD HAD NUMEROUS OPPORTUNITIES TO REMOVE JAMES FROM HIS HOME, BUT DIDN’T. AMBER SAYS THE AGENCY NEEDS AN OVERHAUL. I DO BELIEVE THAT IT NEEDS TO BE COMPLETELY REBUILT FROM THE GROUND UP. THEY NEED TO GET RID OF EVERYBODY AND START FRESH. JAMES’S GRANDFATHER, KEVIN NELSON, FEELS THE SAME. WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE BE DONE WITH CYFD? I’D LIKE TO SEE THE WHOLE PLACE BURNED DOWN AND REBUILT. HOW WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE IT BE REBUILT? WELL, BETTER CHECKS AND BALANCES. NUMBER ONE, MAKE SURE EVERYBODY’S DOING THEIR JOB AND THEY’RE ALL ON BOARD FROM THE SECRETARY ON DOWN, EVERYBODY GETS DOUBLE CHECKED. THAT IDEA WAS ONE OF 30 BILLS THAT WERE PROPOSED IN THE LEGISLATIVE SESSION THAT WOULD HAVE DIRECTLY IMPACTED CYFD LAWMAKERS WANTED TO CREATE AN OMBUDSMAN IN THAT IS A PERSON WHO INDEPENDENTLY INVESTIGATES COMPLAINTS AND TRIES TO RESOLVE THEM. THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE. AG RAUL TORRES SUPPORTED THE IDEA. THERE ISN’T A LOT OF PUBLIC CONFIDENCE AT THIS POINT THAT THE KIND OF INSTITUTION CHANGE THAT WE NEED TO PROTECT KIDS CAN BE ACCOMPLISHED WITHOUT INDEPENDENT OVERSIGHT. THE BILL DIED, BUT TORRES BELIEVES HIS OFFICE CAN STILL DO SOMETHING. HE WOULD LIKE TO FORM A CIVIL RIGHTS DIVISION IN HIS OFFICE THAT COULD PURSUE LEGAL ACTION AGAINST CYFD. IF IT FAILS. THE CIVIL RIGHTS OF A CHILD WERE VIOLATED. LITIGATION IS IS SOMETIMES A NECESSARY TOOL TO BRING ABOUT THE KIND OF SYSTEM INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE THAT I THINK CYFD DESPERATELY NEEDS. 29 OTHER BILLS ALSO DIED IN THE ROUNDHOUSE THAT WOULD HAVE IMPACTED. SEE VFD BILLS THAT WOULD HAVE ALLOWED FOR MORE TRANSPARENCY. WHEN A CHILD DIES. INCREASING REIMBURSEMENT RATES FOR FOSTER PARENTS. AND LIKE WE TOLD YOU EARLIER, CHANGING THE LAW THAT PROHIBITS A BABY BEING TAKEN AWAY FROM A DRUG ADDICTED MOTHER WHEN THEY’RE BORN. WE ASKED LAWMAKERS ON BOTH SIDES WHY THE BILLS FAILED. WHY DIDN’T THEY PASS? THEY JUST NEVER GOT THROUGH ALL THE COMMITTEES AND TO THE FLOORS AT THE APPROPRIATE AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME. PART OF IT WAS THEY HAD HEARD THAT THERE WAS SOME OPPOSITION FROM THE GOVERNOR AND LIKE, SAY, ONCE THEY PASSED, THAT IS HER PRIORITY, HER PREROGATIVE, SHE GETS TO VETO OR SHE GETS TO SIGN IT. THAT’S NOT MY JOB. AS THESE BILLS WERE DEBATED, THE GOVERNOR HELD THIS NEWS CONFERENCE DURING THE LEGISLATIVE SESSION. WE’RE ANNOUNCING TODAY THAT WE ARE GOING TO IMPLEMENT THE STRATEGIES FOR TRANSFORMATION FOR CHILDREN, YOUTH AND FAMILIES DEPARTMENT. SHE ANNOUNCED THAT SHE WAS GOING TO SIGN AN EXECUTIVE ORDER TO REVAMP THE AGENCY. WE HAVE PROBLEMS IN THE INTERIM THAT ARE UNTENABLE. THE ORDER CREATED A POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE, AN INNOVATION OFFICE AND NEW LEADERSHIP TEAMS. SHE ALSO ANNOUNCED THAT SHE WAS GOING TO HIRE AN INDEPENDENT FIRM TO LOOK AT THE AGENCY’S COMPLIANCE AND PROGRESS. TARGET 7 WAS THERE. IT SOUNDS LIKE THIS EXECUTIVE ORDER IS ASKING FOR A CONTRACT WITH AN INDEPENDENT FIRM OUT OF THE STATE. HOW OFTEN WILL YOU BE WORKING WITH THAT FIRM? IS THERE A ROLE TO HOLD THE DEPARTMENT ACCOUNTABLE? NO, THAT’S MY JOB. AND THEN HERE’S WHO HOLDS ME ACCOUNTABLE THE PUBLIC AND THE PUBLIC’S REPRESENTATIVES IN THE LEGISLATURE. IN THE MIDDLE OF OUR INVESTIGATION, CABINET SECRETARY BARBARA VIGIL ANNOUNCED SHE WAS STEPPING DOWN AND NOW THE GOVERNOR IS TRYING TO FIND HER THIRD CYFD SECRETARY. IN THE MEANTIME, THE STATE’S CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER, TERESA CASADO, IS TAKING OVER. AND WE CAUGHT UP WITH HER ABOUT WHAT SHE’S DOING TO FIX THE AGENCY. IT’S AN INCREDIBLY DIFFICULT JOB. AND FROM WHAT I’VE BEEN ABLE TO GATHER SINCE COMING ON BOARD A LITTLE OVER A WEEK AGO, IS THAT WE DON’T HAVE A GOOD RETENTION RATE FOR THOSE EMPLOYEES. I THINK THERE’S A LOT OF BURNOUT FOR THEM. SHE SAYS THE AGENCY IS STREAMLINE REIMBURSEMENT TO FOSTER PARENTS. BUT WHAT ABOUT THE LAWS SOME SAY WOULD FIX CYFD SHOULD MORE HAVE BEEN DONE? THIS LEGISLATIVE SESSION? I DON’T BELIEVE SO. YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT WE WERE HAVING CONVERSATIONS, BIPARTISAN CONVERSATIONS, AND I THINK THAT’S INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT. SO THERE HAVE BEEN NINE DEATHS DUE TO THE CARE ACT SLASH POLICY. DOES CARA NEED TO BE CHANGED? I DON’T KNOW NECESSARILY IF CARA NEEDS TO BE CHANGED OR IF WE REALLY NEED TO LOOK INTERNALLY AND SEE IF THERE ARE POLICIES AND PROCEDURES THAT WE CAN STRENGTHEN. TARGET 7 FOUND NUMEROUS RESEARCH ARTICLES THAT SHOW CHILDREN DO BETTER WHEN RAISED BY THEIR FAMILIES, AND WE LEARNED THAT RESEARCH HAS GUIDED THE DECISIONS THAT ARE BEING MADE BY CYFD FOR YEARS AS THE FUNDAMENTAL BELIEF OF OF, YOU KNOW, OF PRETTY MUCH EVERYONE. IF YOU DIG DOWN INTO IT, THAT PARENTS HAVE A RIGHT TO PARENT. BUT DESPITE THAT PHILOSOPHY DURING OUR INVESTIGATION, IT BECAME CLEAR THAT EVERYONE AGREES OUR STATE HAS BROKEN A PROMISE THAT WAS WRITTEN INTO LAW THAT SAYS THE SAFETY OF A CHILD SHOULD COME FIRST. THE NUMBER ONE PRIORITY OF THAT DEPARTMENT IS PROTECTING CHILDREN AND IMPROVING THEIR WELL-BEING. THAT IS NOT WHAT IS OCCURRING IN THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO. WE’VE GOT A SYSTEM THAT IS TOO FAR TILTED TOWARDS THIS NOTION THAT REUNIFICATION AT ALL COSTS, THEY’LL BE RETURNED TO BIOLOGICAL FAMILY AT ALL COSTS. WE ARE REUNIFICATION FIRST STATE FAMILIES, TIGHT AND BLOOD RUNS THICKER THAN WATER. BUT IF AND WHEN THE DEPARTMENT FIGURES OUT ITS PROBLEMS AND PRIORITIES, IT’S TOO LATE FOR SOME. JAMES IS STILL GONE. I MEAN, JAMES WILL NEVER KNOW THAT JUSTICE WAS DONE. THERE ARE STILL CHILDREN WHO DIED TO A SYSTEM WITH BROKEN PROMISES. THIS WAS SOMETHING THAT JAMES HAD DONE WHEN HE WAS LIVING HERE FOR KEVIN NELSON. ALL HE HAS LEFT TO REMEMBER HIS GRANDSON JAMES, OR HIS TOYS AND THIS DRAWING, AFTER HE PASSED, I JUST DIDN’T HAVE THE HEART TO TAKE IT DOWN. AND IT’S BEEN UP THERE EVER SINCE. IT’S NEVER MOVED. IT’S KIND OF FADED OVER TIME. AND WHILE THE PAIN OF A TRAGIC DEATH WILL FADE WITH TIME AND IT’LL STAY UP THERE FOREVER, NELSON HAS MADE A PROMISE TO JAMES. HE SAYS IT WILL NEVER BE BROKEN, OR WHEN. WHEN MY LIFE IS DONE, I CAN AT LEAST GO FIND HIM AND TELL HIM WE GOT THOSE RESPONSIBLE. YOU KNOW,
Advertisement
Here are the solutions being proposed to fix the system within CYFD
CYFD's practices and policies have drawn scrutiny from many people ranging from politicians, to advocates and families. One thing remans constant, everyone wants change. Many ideas and efforts have been proposed by a wide range of officials on how the system should be changed.In the 2023 New Mexico legislative session, there were 30 bills proposed that would have impacted CYFD.One of the most notable was a bill to create an ombudsman. That person would independently investigate complaints and try to resolve them. That person would've been assigned to the Office of the Attorney General.That bill ultimately died.Several other bills were also proposed.House Bill 11 and Senate Bill 373 were identical bills proposed in the 2023 session. Both aimed to create the Office of The Child Advocate as a legal oversight for CYFD.VIDEO | Learn more about House Bill 11 and Senate Bill 373Lawmakers and supporters said they were trying to pass this for years.“This is our fifth year introducing this bill and it's just so important. Forty-three other states have a similar office, and Idaho and Louisiana are attempting to introduce it as well. So this is a national best practice,” Maralyn Beck with New Mexico Child First Network said at the time of the bill's proposal.The attorney general would have been in charge of the oversight office.“If he is committed to pushing back against CYFD to make sure that our vulnerable children are protected, we want to work with him, someone who is passionate, who will do the job and will provide the oversight that CYFD has failed at for so long," Republican New Mexico state Sen. Crystal Diamond said.SB 373 stalled in the House and HB 11 stalled in the Senate.MORE | Unheard CYFD bills have lawmakers asking questionsWhen Target 7 approached lawmakers about why the bills failed, we were given different reasons.Rep. Marian Matthews said bills never got through committees and to the floors in time.Sen. David Gallegos told us there was opposition from the governor.As the bills were making their way through the legislature, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced an executive order that would help reform the agency.VIDEO | Governor announces changes to CYFDThe order created a policy advisory committee, an innovation office and new leadership teams.Despite those bills failing in the legislature and the governor signing an executive order, Attorney General Raul Torrez believes something else can still be done.He says he wants to form a civil rights division within the AG's office that could pursue legal action if they feel the civil rights of a child were violated.VIDEO | Full interview with Attorney General Raul Torrez"Litigation is sometimes a necessary tool to bring about the kind of systemic institutional change that I think CYFD desperately needs," Torrez said.As changes are made to our state's Children, Youth and Families Department, Target 7 will follow what is being done to protect our state's children.

CYFD's practices and policies have drawn scrutiny from many people ranging from politicians, to advocates and families.

One thing remans constant, everyone wants change.

Advertisement

Many ideas and efforts have been proposed by a wide range of officials on how the system should be changed.

In the 2023 New Mexico legislative session, there were 30 bills proposed that would have impacted CYFD.

One of the most notable was a bill to create an ombudsman. That person would independently investigate complaints and try to resolve them. That person would've been assigned to the Office of the Attorney General.

That bill ultimately died.

Several other bills were also proposed.

House Bill 11 and Senate Bill 373 were identical bills proposed in the 2023 session. Both aimed to create the Office of The Child Advocate as a legal oversight for CYFD.

VIDEO | Learn more about House Bill 11 and Senate Bill 373

Lawmakers and supporters said they were trying to pass this for years.

“This is our fifth year introducing this bill and it's just so important. Forty-three other states have a similar office, and Idaho and Louisiana are attempting to introduce it as well. So this is a national best practice,” Maralyn Beck with New Mexico Child First Network said at the time of the bill's proposal.

The attorney general would have been in charge of the oversight office.

“If he is committed to pushing back against CYFD to make sure that our vulnerable children are protected, we want to work with him, someone who is passionate, who will do the job and will provide the oversight that CYFD has failed at for so long," Republican New Mexico state Sen. Crystal Diamond said.

SB 373 stalled in the House and HB 11 stalled in the Senate.

MORE | Unheard CYFD bills have lawmakers asking questions

When Target 7 approached lawmakers about why the bills failed, we were given different reasons.

Rep. Marian Matthews said bills never got through committees and to the floors in time.

Sen. David Gallegos told us there was opposition from the governor.

As the bills were making their way through the legislature, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced an executive order that would help reform the agency.

VIDEO | Governor announces changes to CYFD

The order created a policy advisory committee, an innovation office and new leadership teams.

Despite those bills failing in the legislature and the governor signing an executive order, Attorney General Raul Torrez believes something else can still be done.

He says he wants to form a civil rights division within the AG's office that could pursue legal action if they feel the civil rights of a child were violated.

VIDEO | Full interview with Attorney General Raul Torrez

"Litigation is sometimes a necessary tool to bring about the kind of systemic institutional change that I think CYFD desperately needs," Torrez said.

As changes are made to our state's Children, Youth and Families Department, Target 7 will follow what is being done to protect our state's children.